After the First 48 (2008)

S4E14 What Lies Beneath

In a gripping After the First 48 special, one of the most unusual cases from The First 48 unfolds. A body, concealed in a basement for six months, is unearthed in an Old Louisville residence, leading to murder charges against the homeowner and his boyfriend. Each accuses the other of committing the horrific act. As the two undergo separate trials, unsettling revelations about their relationship emerge, leaving the entire city of Louisville questioning the true events that transpired within those walls.