After the First 48 (2008)

S2E1 Signs of Violence

In a perplexing case, one victim was entangled in a love triangle while the other was an unknown individual, both meeting gruesome fates just a week apart. Louisville Homicide Detectives initially failed to see the connection between the two murders until they encountered Michael Knights and Jeston Murray. The question loomed: were they both culpable, or was one merely a bystander? With both facing the death penalty, only one would ultimately stand trial for the crimes.