Return to Amish
Overview
The cast of "Breaking Amish" comes together once more in Pennsylvania, catching up on their lives and experiences. Abe, Jeremiah, Rebecca, and Sabrina navigate their new realities, while Kate remains in the bustling atmosphere of New York City. As they reconnect, the group faces the challenges and triumphs of balancing their Amish heritage with modern life, offering viewers a glimpse into their evolving identities and relationships. Tensions rise and bonds are tested as they confront their past and determine what the future holds for each of them.
Episodes
-
1
Home Is Where the Beef Is
The cast of "Breaking Amish"—Abe, Jeremiah, Kate, Rebecca, and Sabrina—reunites in this reality show, starting with a holiday dinner at Mary's tha...
-
2
Shunned & The City
Mary heads to New York City with Kate and Katie Ann, who is thrilled about the chance to meet a local. Back in Pennsylvania, Abe, Rebecca, Sabrina, an...
-
3
I’m Amish, What Are You?
Mary and Chester find themselves in a heated debate over the church. Meanwhile, the Schmuckers visit Abe and Rebecca to meet their new baby. On anothe...
-
4
Six More Weeks Of Winter
Chapel receives some heartbreaking news and struggles to figure out how to break it to Andrew. Meanwhile, Sabrina is given some dubious advice that le...
-
5
Brother, Where Art Thou?
-
6
Rebel Without A Clue
-
7
Second Chances
-
8
The Shunning Truth
-
1
Broken Family
-
2
Under Arrest
-
3
A Real Emergency
-
4
Mother Schmucker’s B&B
-
5
Other Side Of The Fence
-
6
A Secret
-
7
Ultimatum
-
8
Big Decisions
-
1
Judgment Day
-
2
Banished
-
3
Dental Dilemma
-
4
You Lie!
-
5
Breaking Dad
-
6
Rebels Without a Claus
The cast reunites in Pennsylvania for a nostalgic Christmas celebration. However, Kate receives disappointing news regarding her internship, casting a...
-
7
The Announcement
-
8
License to Wed
Mary reaches a conclusion about her future path; Kate faces the challenge of showcasing her talent at Fashion Week LA; the group heads to Jeremiah's w...
-
1
Mary With Children
In the season opener, Sabrina faces a challenging custody fight for Oakley while navigating her pregnancy. Meanwhile, Jeremiah and Carmela are excited...
-
2
I Got You Abe
-
3
Fun in the Shun
-
4
From Here to Maternity
In Florida, the atmosphere calms as everyone reconciles. Jeremiah and Carmela consult a specialist to discuss their chances of starting a family. Mean...
-
5
Chasing Raber
Mary stands by Sabrina as she navigates a custody hearing for her newborn. Meanwhile, Carmela decides to walk away from Jeremiah following a heated co...
-
6
Amish Pair-O-Dice
Mary decides to take Jeremiah and Carmela on the honeymoon they missed out on, heading to Las Vegas. However, tensions rise when a disagreement erupts...
-
1
Leaving Everything Behind
Mary faces a tough choice about returning to the Amish church. Meanwhile, Jeremiah and Carmela take a bold step in an effort to salvage their relation...
-
2
Donut Season
Jeremiah and Carmela welcome Lowell, Shelly, and Dawn into the realm of English life. Tensions rise between Shelly and Lowell, casting a shadow over t...
-
3
Sabrina's Surprise
Lowell, Shelly, and Dawn push back against Jeremiah's strict regulations, venturing into the English world for a taste of freedom. Meanwhile, Mary fac...
-
4
Jeremiah's Dark Past
As Jeremiah launches his donut stand for the very first time, he encounters various obstacles along the way. Meanwhile, Mary steps into church for the...
-
5
Going Full English
After a promising start with the donut stand, friction arises between Jeremiah and Carmela. Meanwhile, Lowell opts for a transformation with a new loo...
-
6
Forgive Me, Carmela
Jeremiah urgently begs Carmela to come back to him. Meanwhile, Dawn and Shelly fully embrace their English side. Lowell faces a tough decision as he r...
-
7
Stay Amish or Go English?
Jeremiah and Ada face a critical decision regarding the direction of their donut stand. Meanwhile, Mary discovers her fate with the Amish Church. Shel...
-
8
No Turning Back
Jeremiah, Carmela, Ada, Dawn, and Lowell come together to celebrate Shelly’s wedding. Shelly is particularly anxious for her Mennonite mother to att...
-
1
The Panic in Amish Park
The pandemic brings Jeremiah, Carmela, Ada, and Sabrina together in Florida. As Sabrina gets ready for the birth of her second child, Jeremiah and Jet...
-
2
The Past Isn’t the Past
Ada introduces Maureen and Rosanna to the ocean for their very first experience, but Rosanna finds herself considering a return to her Amish roots. Me...
-
3
The Time Has Come
As Jeremiah grapples with doubts about his father's legitimacy, he talks to Carmela about the possibility of starting a family. Meanwhile, Maureen and...
-
4
The DNA Test Request
After enduring long hours of labor by herself, Sabrina faces the need for an emergency C-section. Meanwhile, Roseanna grows weary of listening to Maur...
-
5
The Truth About Jeremiah's Dad
Jeremiah discovers the reality about his father. Meanwhile, Rosanna and Maureen excitedly purchase their first swimsuits, only to find out…
-
6
The Most Awkward First Kiss Ever
During an outing with her new friends, Rosanna receives a date invitation. Maureen experiences her first kiss but hesitates about taking the next step...
-
7
The Black Sheep
Following a night of intimacy with Daniel, Maureen becomes anxious over an unusual itch. Meanwhile, Sabrina and Jethro confront each other in a heartf...
-
8
The Family Resemblance
Maureen and Rosanna are faced with a tough choice between embracing an English lifestyle or remaining within their Amish roots. Meanwhile, Jeremiah en...
-
9
The Last Time You See Your Family
Maureen receives some disappointing news from her Amish parents, but finds comfort in her budding romance with Daniel. Meanwhile, Rosanna comes to ter...
-
10
The English Makeover
Ada hosts a celebration to honor Maureen and Rosanna’s transformative English makeovers. When Jeremiah expresses his desire to become a father, Carm...
-
1
Karma Carmela Chameleon
Ada dreams of Maureen coming to Florida with her, while Jeremiah and Carmela take a break from the pressures of trying to conceive. Rosanna faces a to...
-
2
Daniel, My Brother
Johnny feels overwhelmed during his first visit to an English nightclub, while Jeremiah and Carmela come to Sabrina's aid during a medical emergency. ...
-
3
Fannie, Are You OK?
Jethro returns to patch things up with Sabrina. Meanwhile, Kenneth puts his basketball abilities to the test. Rosanna's older brother discovers the de...
-
4
Come On, Maureen
Rosanna's brother angrily confronts Ada, blaming her for undermining the Amish principles within their home. Meanwhile, Jeremiah seeks to make amends ...
-
5
Meet You All the Way, Rosanna Rosanna
Rosanna makes a fervent attempt to convince Johnny to remain in the English world. Meanwhile, Kenneth confronts a sobering truth about his aspirations...
-
6
Smooth Oper-Ada
Daniel introduces an English girl to the family, leaving Fannie feeling devastated. Meanwhile, Ada surprises everyone with the news that she’s decid...
-
7
Johnny B. Goode
The Amish girls experience a surprising tutorial in Brazilian bikini waxing. Meanwhile, Sabrina and Jeremiah take a stand against the newcomers in the...
-
8
What's The Frequency, Kenneth?
Daniel, Kenneth, and Fannie undergo transformations in their English skills. Meanwhile, Jethro pops the question to Sabrina. Back at home, Rosanna and...
-
9
Jeremiah Was A Bullfrog
Kenneth, Daniel, and Fannie share their choice about embracing English life or remaining Amish with their families. Meanwhile, Jeremiah has an emotion...
-
10
Funky Cold Sabrina
Jeremiah honors his father's memory in a heartfelt tribute. Meanwhile, Rosanna’s brother Ray is taken into custody, leaving her and Johnny to naviga...
